Patrick F.02/23/24Probably preaching to the choir here. Anyway - I have lived in a lot of places and I have had a lot of pizza. And having lived many years in New York City, you'd think I've been spoiled for good... More
Lisa C.03/09/24Met the new owner! Very nice man! Pizza, minestrone, and meatball parm sub were all delicious! Fast and courteous service. More
Preamo I.01/10/23I order at least 2 times a week the portions are nice the sausage and peppers sandwich is delicious The chicken noodle soup is as close to grabdma josaphines as I've ever had over all Tony's 5 stars More
Yuly V.08/25/23I have been ordering from Tony's Pizza Café on 1085 Broadway, City of Rahway for the last 8 years usually the same Lunch special that's from 11am till 4pm. I usually order Penne Vodka with... More
Anthony S.08/09/21Saw this spot riding through the area and thought I'd give it a shot. Order: margherita pan pizza with pepperoni, sausage, garlic and peppers and an order of Buffalo wings. The wings were good.... More