Ogonna S.04/28/24Mad Martha's serves delicious homemade ice cream! The texture is perfect and the flavor options are excellent. I highly recommend it! More
Sarah B.08/04/22Mad Martha's is totally worth it - a little overpriced but what isn't on the cape or Martha's Vineyard? I can't even advise you on what flavor to get because they were all good that we tried and... More
Natalie C.07/06/22It was fine. Exactly what you would expect. If you want one scoop, no you cannot get a half scoop of two flavors. One note - if you have a food allergy, I would highly suggest asking the... More
Adrienne N.07/08/23Decent ice cream, it is pretty expensive though. $7.50 for just one scoop, hence why I docked it a star. We got the coconut, snickerdoodle, and sea salt caramel and all were pretty good. It's a... More
Ayden T.07/31/23This shop is very cute :) It is a little pricey, but considering it's a homemade ice-cram shop it's more worth it. Good variety of flavors and good (but not astonishing) ice cream. The waffle cone... More