Amanda L.05/01/24They have great pizza! This local business should be more popular We love their pepperoni pizza and the Goodfellas pizza was awesome as well. I think that's the supreme pizza but they do their... More
Dianne P.05/24/24Pizza and salad bar were amazing. The staff was friendly. There are not that many tables. Prices are average. My biggest complaint is that they MUST clean and dust the restaurant big time;... More
Karen D.04/05/24Visited Goodfellow's Pizza for the second time and it was fantastic! The crust was fresh, marinara and toppings were flavorful. We enjoyed chicken tenders, pepperoni pizza, salad bar, and chicken... More
Charley L.11/11/23Came in today for an early dinner. Small dining area but it was clean and on theme (goodfellas). The food was hella good. We ordered pizza, spicy wings and garlic bread. The food was quick to... More
Cassy S.07/02/23My husband and his family have been going here for decades. The service is great and the pizza is good. It's not the best but it's not the worst. The prices are reasonable. The crust is thinner... More