Hildy M.04/11/24We brought our guests here for dinner. We've been coming since it opened, about 46 years -- and dinner was exceptional. Our relatives from Germany loved their pizzas (shrimp with a request to... More
Jody S.12/03/23Easy parking, old interior, seating is relatively comfortable with a mixture of booths and tables all indoors, service a-ok, pricing so-so, quality of food not so good, only dessert is chocolate... More
Alexandria R.12/28/23This place is ok. Fills the Italian craving but just didn't wow me. I've lived in very Italian dense areas of the east coast and this would not be a go to spot it would be where tourists ate. I... More
Gene L.01/25/24Large pepperoni, mushroom, black olive with anchovies on half. Shelley was (& is) forthright about the menu & her favorites have become ours. Stuffed shells & Chicken Marsala are a couple we... More
Jocy C.09/04/22My manfriend and I were hungry and wanted to try a different Italian place. We ended up ordering from Gaetano's as I had. $10 Uber Cash that I was trying to use up. According to their website,... More