David G.02/20/24Amazing food, huge portions and reasonable prices make for a great dining experience. What Mateo's lacks in ambiance it more than makes up for in quality. The service is great ( Nelly is a prize)... More
Nicholas G.08/29/22Mateo's has some stellar ratings on Yelp. It was good but they made it out to be L&B's or something. The sausage pizza was my favorite and it was your typical pizzeria pie. The pepperoni was solid... More
G K.06/20/23Went with friends to try out Mateos. First thing I look at is the appearance. Most importantly is it clean? Mateos was spotless. I was impressed with the staff. Friendly and attentive. The food... More
Mark V.12/30/21Five enthusiastic stars for a pizzeria that does everything right, great food, service, portions at a great, fair price! I can't recommend this pizzeria enough in the heart of downtown Freehold!!... More
Whitey L.07/11/23Sounds as though the few recent negative reviews all come from the same barely literate individual who has an axe to grind. Don't believe them. The food and service are exceptional. Large... More