Todd P.04/19/24We stumbled upon OddFellows and couldn't have been happier. The regular and soft serve ice cream were great and the service was great as well. The proprietor even filled my Camelbak water bottle... More
Michael C.06/05/24Decent sized ice cream shop near the water, so a really convenient location to stop by at on a hotter day. Unfortunately, many other people had the same idea, and the store was absolutely packed.... More
Liz B.05/13/24A cute little story near the brooklyn bridge with a lot of unique flavors. I tested the banofee pie (my second favorite I enjoyed the banana and graham cracker flavors), the miso peanut butter (... More
Melody C.07/26/23An ice cream float from OddFellows could not have been a better summer treat under the raging sun. We only saw signs for ice cream and boozy root beer floats plastered on the window outside, so it... More
Valerie N.11/29/23Lovely little ice cream shop that served quality ice cream with a good variety of flavors! They're known for their quirky, unique flavors that rotate. I suggest checking in advance if they have... More