Classic NY style pizza. By the slice counter service. Whole Pies. Knots. Calzones. Soda (fountain and bottle). Draft and...
Website: madeinnewyorkpizza.com
Phone: (646) 484-6200
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Amsterdam Ave and W 80th St
Pickup · Delivery
421 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024 477.76 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 571 reviews
10/10 Food was yum! We went around 10pm and to be almost closing time it was very busy. I'd definitely come back if i'm in the area. More
This is the spot when you want a late night slice of pizza or even the whole pie ! We came here around 2pm and it was busy but the service was great, we got our pizza super fast and it was heated... More
Great grandma slices! The favorite today was the veggie with peppers, onions and mushrooms. The upside down was okay. Might have been better if we had eaten it right out of the oven. Tried the... More
Pretty fast service with delicious pizza! Be warned the pizza is extremely oily and heavy, but super yummy! Highly recommend the vodka as well as the spicy pepperoni. More
Amazing NY pizza perfect in all aspects, better that flatbread pizza in Hawaii, it checks all the list for a perfect classic pizza More
