The Pizzeria provides online ordering and delivery, catering, pizzeria to Islip, NY area.
Website: thepizzeriany.com
Phone: (631) 581-9500
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Main St and Willow Ave
591 Main St Islip, NY 11751 517.65 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 44 reviews
Honestly super surprised by this local spot! It used to be Pizza Parm which I was not a fan of at all. The pizzeria has exceptional speciality iced and a solid plain as well. I tried the hot... More
They make good pizza but I was dumbfounded when I was charged $5.80 a slice. I bought 2 slices it cost me $11.60 and they were tiny oddly cut slices. I questioned the price I said for two plain... More
The first time I tried it here was takeout, so it was a small risk. However I was delighted to find that the food was very good! They have dairy-free options or you can customize of course with... More
I usually just get pizza here which is great but today I went meatball parm. Bread was soft but crunchy, meatballs were flavorful, plentiful of cheese and not a lot of sauce (which I asked). I... More
Best pizza in my area (Bay Shore/Islip). Perfect crust, delicious specialty pies, friendly staff, and great BOGO specials if you subscribe to their SMS texts! More
