Kristy A.12/09/23Oh my! It's been too long! We ordered an 18 inch deluxe no green peps extra mushrooms, pepperoni rolls, Carolina sauce wings and a side of Hamilton sauce. I'd never had that sauce but I do love... More
Gabe M.05/14/24Ok so, 5 star pizza as a whole is a great place for pizza. Owner is nice and friendly. It's the managers I have a issue with. I just finished working for them and 3 days before leaving, when I... More
Sebastian M.03/09/24Takeout specials value/delicious ratio of the charts. Affordable is rare these days and it feels like other pizza joints are charging an arm and leg these days. More
T B.09/11/23Veronica is a whole unprofessional mess!! I called to place an order and the lady was beyond rude, kept asking, anything else?. She was beyond rude and she didn't care. I called back to speak to... More
Victor Q.01/06/24Always hot always fresh and you fold it NY style while the hot grease pours out and you slightly burn your tongue and it's just the best slice in Orange Park and dare I say Jacksonville !!! More